The Culture We Carry: How Workplaces Shape Us, and How We Shape Them

Reflections on belonging, cultural conditioning, mutual fit, and the influence we have on the environments we join.

I’ve often wondered whether organizational culture shapes the people who work within it, or whether people create the culture. Looking back on my career, I find it hard to separate the two.

Some workplaces taught me to think differently, approach problems with curiosity and become more empathetic. I’ve also seen how deeply a culture can influence behaviour, sometimes helping people grow and sometimes making them doubt their confidence and their place.

That’s why I believe culture is much more than values displayed on a wall. It influences how we think, how we respond under pressure, how we handle disagreement and how we treat the people around us. And often, without realizing it, we carry those influences into the next organization we join.

The Cultures That Shaped Me

I’ve been fortunate to spend much of my professional life in collaborative, inclusive environments, and I can’t overstate how much they shaped me, not just as a professional but as a person.

One of those workplaces showed me what inclusivity, experimentation, agility and collaborative problem-solving look like in everyday work. The lesson that stayed with me most: when something goes wrong, focus on understanding the problem and finding a solution before looking for someone to blame. That doesn’t mean accountability disappears. It means approaching challenges with curiosity, listening to different perspectives and working together to improve the outcome.

That same workplace also showed me that culture can reach beyond the walls of an organization. Our conversations were never only about delivering good work. In almost every project, almost every day, there was a bigger question underneath: how can our work make life better for people? It shaped the work itself. The organization was deliberate about which projects it took on, and it chose to turn down certain kinds of work, such as gambling or weapons, because of what it believed in. I didn’t fully appreciate it then, but it taught me that a culture’s values show most clearly in what it chooses to do and what it chooses not to do.

My later roles built on that foundation, reinforcing patience, empathy and the importance of staying human when circumstances get difficult.

Working in People & Culture has made those lessons even more relevant. Policies, processes and organizational requirements matter. But behind every difficult situation are people with their own experiences, expectations and circumstances, and taking the time to understand someone’s perspective can change how we approach a decision.

I know the cultures I’ve experienced shape how I work with people today. But I’ve also learned that culture doesn’t influence everyone in the same way.

When Our Past Culture Meets a New One

I remember a manager who joined an organization after years in a more hierarchical environment. They were used to a structure where senior leaders gave direction and junior colleagues followed it. The new environment was quite different: people were encouraged to share opinions, challenge ideas respectfully and contribute beyond their titles.

The adjustment wasn’t easy. Their leadership approach didn’t always match the expectations around them. Through coaching and conversation, we began to see where those behaviours came from. It wasn’t about capability or willingness. Their past experience had shaped how they understood leadership, authority and collaboration. Over time there was learning and adjustment, but some aspects of the new way of working continued to feel unfamiliar.

That experience changed how I think about cultural fit. We often judge fit by how comfortably someone demonstrates certain behaviours, without asking where those behaviours came from. Someone from a highly hierarchical workplace may find it uncomfortable to challenge leadership. Someone from a blame-oriented workplace may take time to trust an environment where mistakes are treated as learning. That doesn’t make either a poor fit. People often need to experience a different way of working before they can understand or embrace it.

At the same time, conditioning isn’t the only factor. Individual beliefs, preferences and willingness to adapt matter too. Coaching can help people understand new expectations and build new behaviours, but adapting and genuinely aligning aren’t always the same thing.

Before deciding someone doesn’t fit a culture, we need to understand what has shaped them, and whether we’ve given them a fair chance to grow within it.

When Belonging Becomes a Boundary

People sometimes describe their workplace as a “tribe,” referring to strong relationships, shared history and a deep sense of connection. I understand that feeling. There’s something wonderful about working with people who trust one another and genuinely enjoy being part of a group.

But I’ve seen another side. When people in an established group become very comfortable with one another, invisible boundaries can form. It isn’t always deliberate. People naturally build friendships, shared experiences and familiar ways of working. But for someone new, entering that circle can be surprisingly hard. I’ve seen a distinction emerge between the “seasoned” and the “unseasoned,” those who have been there for years and those still trying to find their place.

What concerns me is what happens next. People who want to be accepted may start adopting communication styles or unwritten practices that don’t reflect who they are. They may hold back from questioning something, not because they agree, but because they don’t want to feel like outsiders. Over time, I’ve seen this wear down people’s confidence, enthusiasm and sense of worth. Sometimes it breaks their spirit, which is especially hard to accept when the same culture is making others feel connected and supported.

A culture can feel wonderfully inclusive to those already inside it and deeply isolating to someone trying to find their place.

It has made me question how we measure a culture’s strength. Is it enough that established colleagues feel connected, or should we also ask how newcomers experience the same environment? Strong relationships are valuable, but belonging shouldn’t require becoming a copy of the people around you. A healthy culture makes room for people to bring their own experiences, opinions and identities without making acceptance depend on conformity.

When Cultural Pride Becomes a Blind Spot

Strong cultures have another consequence I’ve observed. People can become so attached to a culture they helped create that it becomes part of their professional identity. There’s genuine pride in belonging to an organization that feels different or special, and nothing wrong with that.

But that pride can slowly harden into a belief that our way of working is superior to what exists elsewhere. People start to assume newcomers have more to learn than to contribute. Established practices become hard to question, not because they still work, but because they’re tied to the organization’s identity. The very qualities that built the culture, shared beliefs, strong relationships and a sense of ownership, can make it resistant to learning from others.

This is part of why diversity in hiring matters, including diversity of professional experience. People bring more than technical skills. They bring habits, leadership expectations and approaches formed in other workplaces. When several people share similar backgrounds, they can reinforce familiar ways of thinking, which may introduce valuable practices or create friction with the existing environment. Neither outcome should be assumed based on where someone previously worked. What matters is whether people are willing to learn from one another.

Professional background is only one dimension of diversity, and it doesn’t replace representation, equity and inclusion. But it can help organizations question assumptions they no longer realize they’re making.

Protecting a healthy culture doesn’t mean protecting every existing practice. Some things deserve to be preserved and others need to evolve. Often, the people joining are the ones who help us tell the difference.

Cultural Fit Shouldn’t Be Forced

Organizations often ask, “Will this person fit our culture?” Individuals should be asking an equally important question: “Will this culture help me thrive?”

Mutual fit matters. A highly capable person may struggle in an environment that doesn’t match how they work best. Sometimes understanding, feedback, coaching and time can close that gap. But not every difference can or should be resolved by endless efforts to change someone.

There’s an important distinction between three people: someone who thinks differently, someone who needs time to adapt, and someone whose continued behaviour undermines trust, respect, collaboration or accountability. The first may bring exactly the perspective an organization needs. The second deserves support and a fair chance to adjust. The third needs honest feedback and appropriate action.

When genuine misalignment in behaviour continues despite reasonable efforts, it can be healthier to acknowledge that the relationship isn’t working for either side. But that conversation must be fair, respectful and grounded in clear expectations and actual behaviours, never in someone’s personality, background or willingness to challenge existing practices.

What Do We Carry Forward?

The lessons organizations have given me are relatively easy to name. Some taught me to collaborate. Others encouraged me to question assumptions, value different perspectives and stay patient when things got hard.

The reverse question is harder: what have I contributed to the cultures I’ve been part of? I hope I’ve carried forward some of what I learned: listening before judging, approaching problems constructively and trying to stay human when circumstances are difficult.

We tend to associate cultural contribution with big initiatives and transformation programs. Those matter. But culture is also shaped in small moments: how we respond when someone makes a mistake, whether we welcome someone who is struggling to belong, how we react when an unfamiliar view challenges our assumptions, and whether we help people grow in confidence or quietly diminish it. Repeated over time, these moments define what it feels like to work somewhere.

I’ve seen cultures help people discover capabilities they didn’t know they had. I’ve also seen environments make capable people question their worth. That’s why organizations and individuals both need to be conscious of the influence they have on each other. Organizations must create conditions where people can learn, contribute and thrive. Individuals must bring openness, respect, accountability and a willingness to grow. Neither can do it alone.

Which brings me back to my opening question: does culture build people, or do people build culture?

Both build each other. Culture shapes our thinking, confidence, behaviour and beliefs. People, through everyday actions, reinforce, challenge and gradually change the culture they join. That influence isn’t always positive: cultures can hold people back, and people can create boundaries or resist the changes that would help a culture grow.

The most meaningful cultures aren’t necessarily the ones that stay unchanged. They’re the ones that preserve what’s valuable while staying open to learning and evolving through their people.

A strong culture should do more than make the people within it feel proud. It should help them grow, welcome those who bring different perspectives, and remain open to questioning its own practices. And perhaps its greatest strength lies in recognizing that it will always be a work in progress.

Because ultimately, we don’t just work within a culture. We carry parts of it with us, contribute parts of ourselves to it, and together shape what it becomes.


What’s one lesson you’ve carried from a previous workplace into your current one?

AI transparency note: This article was developed with AI assistance for structuring, drafting and editing. The reflections are based on my personal professional experiences, learning and perspectives.

Leave a Reply